RE: update #13

letters to editor

Dear Editor,
I am writing to you in reply to the “Argyll Array Project Update No 13.”

Visual Impact Vs Socio-Economics.

I find it hard to believe that no one at SPR has highlighted any connection between the visual impact and a negative impact on the Socio Economic situation on Tiree. As we all know tourism brings a significant amount of sustainable income and related employment to the Island.

After speaking to tourists over the summer period, many of them value the peace, unspoiled scenery and rural environment that makes Tiree such a unique holiday destination. How does SPR intend to convince us that tourism will not be affected by the erection of this unprecedented sized wind farm so close to our shores? Will any spin off benefits merely fill the void caused by the negative impact of the development? How many people may become unemployed through a decline in tourism? Perhaps rather than another non-committal response, SPR might give us some firm assurances about how they intend to address and reassure us on this particular matter in the very near future.


While SPR prefers to dismiss or undermine anyone who questions the accuracy of the visualisations they recently produced, I would still like to seek further assurance on this topic.

Some worrying points are that their images were taken at a time of day when the light was most favourable to hide the impact of the turbines. Information from the Met office confirms that later in the same day the visibility was greatly superior.

I also noted that in none of their visualisations did any of the turbines appear in the foreground. All of the turbines appear on the the horizon or further away. The picture taken from Sandaig has a turbine at 6 km distance but it appears on the horizon, however a conservative estimate of the height from which the picture was taken puts the horizon at 10 km away. Is this a deliberate mistake by SPR to reduce the visual proximity of their development?

Although the visualisations in their present form may be shocking to many, can SPR actually convince us that the reality will be no worse? SPR’s is, to date, unwilling to publish these visualisations on their website (after numerous requests) this along with the disclaimer which seems to appear on most SPR publications to the community (relieving SPR of any legal responsibility on their accuracy) does nothing to reassure me.

Personal Viewpoint.

Although throughout this letter I have expressed my own personal point of view I would like to make a comment on the ‘Updates’ in the An Tirisdeach from the SPR Representative.

In the last update I felt that rather than feel like I was getting factual responses from SPR, I was reading the personal opinions from the SPR Representative. I believe it would be more beneficial for those of us who are closely following the developments, to feel like comments and feedback are being addressed directly from the senior management at SPR and information in the An Tirisdeach is coming directly from ‘ the SPR decision makers’ too.

Speculation from the SPR Representative on issues like the ‘ main view’ of public reaction to the visualisations, I believe should not be made in this official capacity when the community is hoping for accountable/factual responses from SPR instead.

Finally, the first item in the “Update” is a desire from the community to see something in return for any negative impact. Indicating that most people are expecting that that wind farm is going to have a negative impact on the island.

The worrying fact is that in the same section SPR Representative says, “we are committed, however, to responsibly discussing potential benefits with the island as soon as they are identified”. On this basis, is this an admission that presently SPR does not currently see any guaranteed benefits for the Island as some of us already fear?

Best regards,
Adam Milne


  • This is getting insane!! Step into the 21st centuary and spend time lamenting something else instead of trying in vain to stop the inevitable!
    I wonder how many man hours this has taken up from peoples time, look to the positives like the environment and the future of the planet people seem so keen to ruin!

    End it!

  • Dear “Fed up Hearing it”,

    I for one would be very grateful if you could show me the evidence to support your claim that huge industrial wind farms are positive to the environment. What are we going to use to generate electricity when the wind is not blowing? Yes thats correct fossil fuels!
    How can you claim that building this wind farm is going to save the future of the planet when it is going to cause such wide spread damage to the sea bed.
    Do you know how much energy goes into creating the cement to attach these giant structures to the sea bed?
    Do you think I would be wasting many man hours on this if I thought for one minute that there was going to be a positive impact to either the environment or the island in general?

  • @Fed up Hearing it

    So during the 80’s when Tiree was chosen as a place to dump nuclear waste we and I quote should:

    “Step into the 21st centuary and spend time lamenting something else instead of trying in vain to stop the inevitable!”

    Now that is insane.

  • I totally agree with the OP, this is insane, its going to happen, No its not ideal, but can we stop it, NO!
    Renewable energy is the way forward, we have to look at it positively, Adam & Nathan I know you havent lived in Tiree all your life so your facts about the Nuclear Waste arent 100% accurate, not all ‘locals’ are against this and it seems the ‘non locals’ such as yourselves are taking such a lot to do with it, what are you trying to prove??
    ‘Fed Up Hearing it’maybe check your spelling before posting??? Its Spelled Century!

  • @Tirisdeach
    It seems that you prefer to hide behind a pseudonym and make the distinction between “locals” and “non locals”. Quite a controversial comment but not unexpected. Us non locals who have only lived in Tiree for the past 31 years are surely entitled to our opinion?

  • How can anybody say that turbines like that in as big a quantity will not b detrementsl to tourism on the island. Yes we need sustainable power but not like that of a beautiful island like that . U could have wave power which wood not b seen but it won’t benefit the island or it’s people. For the record I am local not lived on the island in years but was brought up there and still have family seeing as u seem to only b allowed to voice a opinion if u aren’t a incomer

  • @Tirisdeach

    Think u need to focus on the Array and shelve the local/non local thing, very devisive. I went to school with Nathan & Adam and Hanna was born on Tiree so these guys are locals as far as most are concerned. Anyhow, there is no devine right that only people born on Tiree get a say in the future of Tiree.

    As it happens, I agree that it will happen and Tiree has to maximise the benefits, whatever they may be. The Array may bring positives, it may also bring negatives, problem is that the positives cannot be quantified yet, however I personally believe that Tiree needs investment and this may be the only chance Tiree has.

    Don’t make decisions without the facts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.